How effective are creams and tablets for the treatment of cold sores?

Photo of a woman using an ointment (PantherMedia / imagepointfr)

Antiviral drugs like aciclovir or penciclovir can make cold sores go away about one day sooner. If you decide to use one, it’s important to start the treatment as soon as you notice the first signs of a cold sore.

Cold sores are bothersome. They can greatly affect your quality of life, particularly if you have them several times a year. Antiviral drugs can speed up the healing process somewhat and reduce the severity of the symptoms.

It’s important to use these drugs properly: The treatment should be started within 24 hours of the first symptoms arising – the sooner, the better. This is true for tablets, as well as for medication that is applied from the outside (topical medication). If the treatment is started later, it might not help anymore because the viruses will have already spread along the nerve fibers. Topical cold sore medications can be bought in pharmacies without a prescription, and antiviral medications are only available with a prescription.

Topical medications

Creams, gels and ointments containing the drugs aciclovir or penciclovir are available in pharmacies without a prescription. Studies have shown that they can make cold sores go away about one day sooner. They can also reduce the severity of symptoms somewhat.

For them to be able to work, they have to be applied to the affected area every 2 to 3 hours during the daytime. The treatment lasts five days.

How effective is the combination drug?

There is also a combination drug (trade name: Zovirax Duo) that contains both aciclovir and a mild steroid. One study looked into whether this combination drug can lower the risk of cold sore blisters and scabs forming. The drug was either compared with aciclovir used alone or with a non-medicated cream (placebo). The people in the study had an average of 5 to 6 cold sores per year, and their cold sores often crusted over and formed scabs. They started using the treatment as soon as they noticed the first signs of a cold sore developing.

The study suggests that the combination of aciclovir and a steroid is somewhat more effective than aciclovir alone. Expressed in numbers, it was found that blisters and scabs formed in

  • 65 out of 100 people who used aciclovir alone, and in
  • 58 out of 100 people who used the combination drug.

In other words: Compared to aciclovir alone, the combination drug prevented the development of blisters and scabs in an extra 7 out of 100 people.

Topical treatments for cold sores can sometimes irritate the skin a bit, but no serious side effects occurred in the studies.

Oral medications

The antiviral drugs aciclovir, famciclovir and valaciclovir are also available in the form of tablets. Research has shown that treatment with these tablets can make cold sores go away about one day sooner in people who are otherwise healthy.

Antiviral tablets are well tolerated. In studies, they weren’t found to cause more side effects than placebo medication did. But people who have kidney failure might have to use a lower dose.

One advantage of tablets is that – unlike ointments and creams – they only have to be taken once or twice a day. Depending on the type and dose of the tablets, the treatment lasts 1 to 7 days.