Do dietary supplements prevent AMD?

Photo of an elderly woman in the garden (PantherMedia / Ralf Winter)

There is no evidence that dietary supplements can prevent age-related macular degeneration (AMD). But certain combinations of vitamins and minerals may help delay the development of late-stage AMD.

Dietary supplements contain nutrients that also occur naturally in our food, such as vitamins and minerals, but in a concentrated form and often at a higher dose. They may contain herbal substances like St. John's wort (hypericum) or garlic, or animal products such as fish oil. Dietary supplements are available in various forms, including tablets, capsules, powder or liquids. You can buy them without a prescription and in different kinds of shops – not just in pharmacies.

How are dietary supplements thought to influence AMD?

Macular degeneration leads to the gradual loss of central vision. According to one common theory, light and oxygen cause substances called “free radicals” to form in the retina, where they may damage the tissue. Dietary supplements are thought to help reduce this process, preventing AMD or slowing down its progression in this way.

Some products for the treatment of AMD contain a combination of different vitamins, such as vitamin C, vitamin E and beta-carotene. They may have copper or zinc in them too. Omega-3 fatty acids, zeaxanthin, lutein and Ginkgo biloba are also commonly recommended.

Can dietary supplements prevent AMD?

There is currently no scientific proof that these products can prevent AMD in people who have healthy retinas. The only substances that have been carefully studied are vitamin E and beta-carotene. Studies involving over 75,000 participants have shown that these products aren't able to lower the probability of AMD developing. There are no good-quality studies on products containing omega-3 fatty acids.

Can dietary supplements slow down the progression of AMD?

This question has been looked into in studies on the substances zinc, lutein, zeaxanthin, vitamin C, vitamin E, beta-carotene, omega-3 fatty acids and Ginkgo biloba. There is no evidence to suggest that omega-3 fatty acids or Ginkgo help.

Taking the following combinations of nutrients daily can possibly slow down the progression of AMD:

  • The “AREDS” formula, containing vitamin C (500 mg), vitamin E (400 I.U.), beta-carotene (15 mg), zinc (80 mg) and copper (2 mg)
  • The nearly identical “AREDS 2” formula, containing vitamin C (500 mg), vitamin E (400 I.U.), zinc (80 mg), copper (2 mg), lutein (10 mg) and zeaxanthin (2 mg)

So far, only people who have a considerably higher risk of developing late-stage AMD have been shown to benefit from the AREDS supplements. People are at higher risk if they already have many deposits in their eyes, called drusen. Taking AREDS supplements regularly lowered the risk of late-stage AMD associated with loss of vision in some of them. In order to be effective, the supplements had to be taken daily for several years.

It's important to talk with your doctor before taking these products because they aren't suitable for everyone. German health insurers don't cover the costs of the AREDS formula.

Just how effective is the AREDS formula?

One large study known as the “AREDS study” (Age-Related Eye Disease Study), involving about 3,600 participants, suggest that the AREDS supplements have a positive effect. The study lasted 6 years. During this time, the progression of vision loss was slowed down a little in some people who used the AREDS formula, but most of them didn't benefit from it. Expressed in numbers:

  • Without treatment: Vision worsened considerably within the six years in about 43 out of 100 participants.
  • With treatment: This happened in about 37 out of 100 participants who took the AREDS formula.

In other words, 6 out of 100 people benefited from taking these supplements every day for six years.

What are the possible side effects of dietary supplements?

The long-term use of dietary supplements at high doses can sometimes be harmful. Beta-carotene, for example, increases the risk of lung cancer in people who smoke or used to. The beta-carotene in the AREDS formula caused lung cancer in 1 out of 100 study participants. Nearly all of the people who developed lung cancer over the course of the study were ex-smokers.

The AREDS 2 formula, which contains lutein and zeaxanthin instead of beta-carotene, is now available. People who used to smoke, or still do, need to make sure they use a product that doesn't have beta-carotene in it.

Products containing beta-carotene caused some participants’ skin to turn yellow. There were also problems such as constipation, bloating and diarrhea.

In 3 out of 100 participants, taking supplements that only contained zinc led to urological problems requiring hospital treatment. These included problems such as bladder infections and incontinence.

Other studies have shown that high doses of vitamin E can increase the risk of death. But in the six-year study on the AREDS formula there weren't an abnormally high number of deaths in the group taking the formula.

Labels: Age-related macular degeneration, Aging and geriatric care, AMD, H35, H36, H54, Head and nerves, Macular degeneration